After this lesson you can join two short sentences into one with who, which or whose, and put the commas in the right place. A non-defining relative clause gives extra information about a noun the reader already knows. Learners often write two short sentences instead, or they use "that" after a comma, which is always wrong. This lesson shows you one simple test, the right pronoun for each case, and the comma rule.
Written by Dr. Kara Abdolmaleki, PhD · TESL Canada · Certified CELPIP Instructor L1 · Last reviewed 2026-11-20 · Start level B1 (CLB 5) · Target level B2 (CLB 7)
Try first
Choose the best answer. Do not worry about the score yet.
"Which sentence is correct?" A) My sister, that lives in Halifax, is a nurse. B) My sister, who lives in Halifax, is a nurse.
The answer is B. After a comma, we never use "that". For a person, use "who".
Examples
The idea in three sentences. A non-defining relative clause adds extra information about a person, place or thing that is already clear. If you remove the clause, the sentence still makes sense and still points to the same person or thing. Put a comma before and after it, use who for people, which for things and whose for possession, and never use that.
Noun + , who / which / whose ..., + rest of the sentence
Example: "My landlord, who lives upstairs, fixed the heater." Take out the middle part and you still have a full sentence: "My landlord fixed the heater."
Climb the ladder. Here is the same skill, describing life in a new city, at three levels.
B1 to B2: join two sentences
B1 weakI live in Winnipeg. Winnipeg is very cold in winter.
B2 betterI live in Winnipeg, which is very cold in winter.
What changed: the B2 sentence joins two short sentences. "Which" points back to Winnipeg, so the city name is not repeated.
B2 to C1: comment on a whole idea
B2 betterThe bus was 40 minutes late. Because of this, I missed my interview.
C1 strongThe bus was 40 minutes late, which meant that I missed my interview.
What changed: in the C1 sentence, "which" points back to the whole first idea, not to one noun. It links a cause and a result in one sentence.
How It Works
Defining or non-defining?
Defining clause: which one? It tells the reader which person or thing you mean, so the sentence needs it. No commas. "The doctor who works on Saturdays is very kind." (The clinic has several doctors. This clause tells us which one.)
Non-defining clause: extra information. The reader already knows who or what you mean. Use commas. "Dr. Chen, who works on Saturdays, is very kind." (The name already tells us who.)
The pronouns. who for people, which for things, animals and whole ideas, whose for possession ("my neighbour, whose dog barks all night"), where for places ("Moncton, where my cousin lives"). In formal writing, whom is used when the person is the object: "My manager, whom I trust, helped me." In speech, who is fine.
The test. Cover the clause with your finger. If the reader still knows exactly who or what you mean, it is non-defining: add commas.
Use this when you
- describe a family member, a city or a workplace with one extra detail
- write a report or an essay and want fewer short, choppy sentences
- explain a result in one sentence: ", which meant that..."
- describe a chart and add a fact about one category
Remember
- Put commas on both sides of the clause. If the clause ends the sentence, use a comma before it and a full stop after it.
- Never use that after a comma. Write "Toronto, which...", not "Toronto, that...".
- Do not repeat the subject: "my son, who is six", not "my son, who he is six".
- You cannot leave out the pronoun in a non-defining clause. "The book I read" is fine (defining), but "Halifax, I visited last year," is not.
- Names of people and places usually take a non-defining clause, because there is only one of them.
Common Mistakes
That after a comma
WeakToronto, that is the largest city in Canada, has very high rents.
StrongToronto, which is the largest city in Canada, has very high rents.
Fix: after a comma, use which for things and who for people. That is only for defining clauses.
Missing second comma
WeakMy manager, who started in May is very helpful.
StrongMy manager, who started in May, is very helpful.
Fix: close the clause with a second comma before the main verb comes back.
Extra pronoun
WeakMy neighbour, who she is a nurse, works nights.
StrongMy neighbour, who is a nurse, works nights.
Fix: who already takes the place of "she". Do not add a second subject.
Which for a person
WeakMy family doctor, which is very busy, sees me once a year.
StrongMy family doctor, who is very busy, sees me once a year.
Fix: use who for people and which for things.
In your test
- IELTS: in Writing Task 1, a clause can add a fact about one category: "Coal, which was the main source in 1990, fell to 10% by 2020." In Writing Task 2, it joins ideas so your sentences are not all short. Grammatical Range and Accuracy is one of the four writing criteria, so correct commas matter.
- CELPIP: in Writing Task 1 (an email), you can give background in one sentence: "My neighbour, whose dog barks all night, has not answered my notes." In Speaking Task 2 (Talking about a Personal Experience), it helps you add detail without stopping.
Related lessons: for clauses that tell us which one, see relative clauses with who and which. To shorten clauses, see short relative clauses. For clauses with a preposition such as "in which", see prepositions in relative clauses, and for the other comma rules, comma usage.
Practice Lab
Now you try
Eight tasks with 13 questions. Use the test: cover the clause. Is the person or thing still clear?
Score: 0/8
Ask yourself: a person, a thing or a whole idea? Then check the commas.
1. Quick pick
"My mother, ___ lives in Surrey, visits us every Sunday."
2. Quick pick
"Calgary, ___ hosted the 1988 Winter Olympics, is in Alberta."
3. Quick pick
Which sentence needs commas around the relative clause?
4. Quick pick (stretch)
"Our rent went up by $200, ___ means we have to move."
5. Build it
Build a sentence about your landlord.
Tap a chunk to move it between the bank and your answer.
6. Build it
Build a sentence about a place.
Tap a chunk to move it between the bank and your answer.
7. Build it (stretch)
Build a sentence with whose.
Tap a chunk to move it between the bank and your answer.
8. Sort it
Is each sentence correct, or does it need a fix?
My father, who is a mechanic, fixed my car.
Vancouver, that is on the west coast, has mild winters.
The students who finished early left the room.
My boss, which is from Ghana, speaks four languages.
I failed the first test, which made me study harder.
My best friend, who she lives in Paris, called me.
Why It Matters
Why it matters: examiners notice when you can join ideas in one clear sentence. Non-defining clauses add detail and range, and correct commas show control. Both IELTS and CELPIP reward a mix of simple and complex sentences that are also accurate.
- Use commas when the clause adds extra information about something already clear.
- Choose who for people, which for things and ideas, whose for possession; never that after a comma.
- Use , which to comment on a whole idea: "..., which meant that..."
Your turn. Write three sentences: one about your city with which, one about a person you know with who or whose, and one about a recent event that ends with ", which meant that...".